Proposed Comprehensive Development at Wo Shang Wai, Yuen Long banner
 
 
 
Ad hoc Event
Project Update >Ad hoc Event
  In early February 2010, pond draining abutting to the northern site boundary was carried out by the adjacent fish ponds owner for bund strengthening and reprofiling for the reprovision of pond bunds for normal fish pond operation.  
 

 
 

This incidence attracted wetland bird species including the Black-faced Spoonbills (BFS) foraging at the partially drained ponds. In order to minimize the disturbance impact on the BFS during the preparation works for the establishment of site hoarding at the northern site boundary, the following protocol has been implemented in early February 2010 :

 
     
 
  1. During the drain down period, our Ecological Consultant (Asia Ecological Consultant (AEC)) will check the ponds at 07:30.
  2. If more than 10 BFS are present, no activities should be undertaken on-site within 150 m of the pond.
  3. AEC will then check the ponds at 10:00, if less than 10 birds are present activities within 150 m of the pond can restart.
  4. If more than 10 are present, checks will be made by AEC at two-hourly intervals until less than 10 birds are present at which time activities within 150 m of the pond can restart
  5. If more than ten BFS are present at 07:30, but activities within 150 m of the pond restart during the course of the day, all activities within 150 m of the pond should cease at 17:00
  6. Until AEC have confirmed with the Site Agent each day that less than 10 birds are present there should be no activity whatsoever within 150 m of the ponds.
  7. If at any time more than 10 BFS are noted when construction activities are on-going the contractor will suspend works within 150 m of the pond immediately and monitoring will be initiated according to items 3 and 4 of this protocol.
 
     
  This protocol is now being followed and is proving effective in minimizing disturbance to Black-faced Spoonbills in the area from the current activities on site.  However, it has been noted during the monitoring that other sources of disturbance to birds are present in the area, specifically the routine activities of fish pond operators have resulted in disturbance to Black-faced Spoonbills.  It is noted that numbers of Black-faced Spoonbills using the ponds remained low over the Chinese New Year holiday, which indicates that other factors beyond the current activities on site also influence the use of these ponds by Black-faced Spoonbills.  A summary of the numbers of spoonbills recorded during the ad hoc  
     
 

Date

BFS Sightings in Adjacent Ponds

10-2-2010

none

11-2-2010

none

12-2-2010

none

13-2-2010

none

15-2-2010

none

16-2-2010

3 BFS at pond north of G1a

17-2-2010

none

18-2-2010

39 BFS at pond north of G1 (Pond 2)

19-2-2010

23 in ponds to the west of Palm Springs

21-2-2010

9 BFS at Pond G1b

22-2-2010

none

23-2-2010

10 BFS at Pond G1b

24-2-2010

58 BFS at Pond G1b

25-2-2010

25 BFS at Pond G1b

26-2-2010

none

27-2-2010

21 BFS at Pond H2

 
     
 

We understand from the fish pond operators in ponds abutting to the Site that drain down of the remaining two ponds is expected in the very near future. Since Black-faced Spoonbills forage opportunistically in draining ponds, these two ponds may be temporarily attractive to the spoonbills. In view of this, a precautionary approach is considered and all bund re-provisioning and strengthening work is being stopped until the drain down of these ponds has been completed and the attraction to Black-faced Spoonbills has ceased. After which, the protocol described above will be resumed until the erection of the site hoarding and/or noise barrier along the northern side of the site, which is expected to screen out any disturbance impacts which might have on the birds.

 
     
     
 
 
   
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2014© Mott MacDonald Hong Kong Ltd
 
Last revision date: 2014/2/19